Chris Brown's fragility over the past two seasons has been a constant source of frustration for fantasy owners.  After playing in only 11 games each of the past two years, Brown broke a bone in his hand during Titans mini-camp this summer.  He is expected to be back in the lineup when the Titans start the preseason.  When available, Brown is an explosive perimeter runner capable of going the distance on any play.  Brown even led the league in yards per carry in 2004. 

Based on the team's recent acquisition of formerly disgruntled Bills RB Travis Henry, it is clear that the Titans' brass was growing tired of Brown's inability to stay healthy.  Now with one year left on his deal, and Travis Henry signing a 4 year contract extension with Tennessee, fantasy owners are left to wonder what the future will hold for these two former 1,000 yard backs. 

Comments from team officials indicate that the "running back by committee" (RBBC) approach will likely be used.  Coach Jeff Fisher said last week that he "wouldn't be suprised" if Henry and Brown each got around 200 carries this season.  GM Floyd Reese upon signing Henry, basically said that a lot will be asked of both backs in Norm Chow's new offense.  

Now let's examine the situation a little more closely.  Notice that Chris Brown was possibly the most ineffective back in the NFL last situation in short yardage situations.  Third and fourth and one turned into play action territory late last year after weeks of Brown coming up short on the ground.  With Henry's ability to pound the ball between the tackles and earn the tough yards, you will likely see him on the field in short yardage and goal line situations.  Brown will be used more between the twenty's and in the passing game.  Henry, however will likely outpace Brown's touchdown totals. 

Look for Brown to hit the occasional home run, like he did twice versus Green Bay on Monday Night last season.  However, his inconsistency in short yardage, inopportune fumbles, and inability to stay healthy will likely make Henry the better fantasy bet this season.  I look for Brown to finish with around 750 yards rushing and 7 touchdowns in around 12 games, while Henry will play 15 games with 650 yards and 12 touchdowns.  Those factors, coupled with the organizations long term commitment to Henry, should make him the better choice.