| Worst Individual Picks of the 2009 Draft |
| Rank | Player | Team | Ranked Value | Selected Value | Difference |
1 | *Darrius Heyward-Bey (WR) - Maryland | OAK | 670 | 1775 | -1105 | 2 | Tyson Jackson (DE) - LSU | KC | 1450 | 2500 | -1050 | 3 | *Andre Smith (OT) - Alabama | CIN | 950 | 1950 | -1000 | 4 | *Matthew Stafford (QB) - Georgia | DET | 2200 | 2800 | -600 | 5 | Michael Mitchell (DB) - Ohio | OAK | 1 | 430 | -429 | 6 | Larry English (OLB) - Northern Illinois (DE) | SD | 530 | 950 | -420 | 7 | Pat White (WR) - West Virginia (QB) | MIA | 99 | 460 | -361 | 8 | Sebastian Vollmer (OT) - Houston | NE | 33 | 323 | -290 | 9 | Eric Wood (OC) - Louisville | BUF | 380 | 670 | -290 | 10 | Mohamad Massaquoi (WR) - Georgia
| CLE | 118 | 400 | -282 | 11 | Patrick Chung (S) - Oregon | NE | 283 | 560 | -277 | 12 | David Veikune (OLB) - Hawaii | CLE | 114 | 380 | -266 | 13 | Richard Quinn (TE) - North Carolina | DEN | 13 | 275 | -262 | 14 | Darcel McBath (S) - Texas Tech | DEN | 163 | 420 | -257 | 15 | *Mark Sanchez (QB) - USC | NYJ | 1950 | 2200 | -250 | 16 | Jason Williams (OLB) - Western Illinois | DAL | 1 | 241 | -240 | 17 | *Josh Freeman (QB) - Kansas State | TB | 690 | 925 | -235 | 18 | Terrance Knighton (DT) - Temple | JAC | 1 | 223 | -222 | 19 | Derek Cox (CB) - William & Mary | JAC | 1 | 218 | -217 | 20 | Robert Brewster (OT) - Ball State | DAL | 1 | 208 | -207 | 21 | *Jairus Byrd (S) - Oregon | BUF | 291 | 480 | -189 | 22 | Bradley Fletcher (CB) - Iowa | STL | 78 | 261 | -183 | 23 | *Donald Brown (RB) - Connecticut | IND | 510 | 690 | -180 | 24 | Louis Vasquez (OG) - Texas Tech
| SD | 20 | 193 | -173 | 25 | Matt Shaughnessy (DE) - Wisconsin | OAK | 60 | 229 | -169 | 26 | Mike Wallace (WR) - Mississippi | PIT | 1 | 163 | -162 | 27 | DeAndre Levy (OLB) - Wisconsin | DET | 50 | 203 | -153 | 28 | *Percy Harvin (WR) - Florida (Inj) | MIN | 650 | 800 | -150 | 29 | Patrick Turner (WR) - USC | MIA | 1 | 148 | -147 | 30 | *Glenn Coffee (RB) - Alabama | SF | 66 | 213 | -147 | 31 | Andy Levitre (OG) - Oregon State | BUF | 247 | 390 | -143 | 32 | Chris Owens (CB) - San Jose State | ATL | 1 | 134 | -133 | 33 | Brian Cushing (OLB) - USC | HOU | 850 | 975 | -125 | 34 | Robert Ayers (DE) - Tennessee | DEN | 775 | 900 | -125 | 35 | Ryan Mouton (CB) - Hawaii | TEN | 1 | 118 | -117 | 36 | *Kenny Britt (WR) - Rutgers | TEN | 520 | 630 | -110 | 37 | Corvey Irvin (DT) - Georgia | CAR | 19 | 122 | -103 | 38 | Brandon Tate (WR) - North Carolina (Inj) | NE | 80 | 168 | -88 | 39 | Henry Melton (DE) - Texas | CHI | 1 | 86 | -85 | 40 | Fili Moala (DT) - USC | IND | 261 | 341 | -80 | 41 | *Brian Hartline (WR) - Ohio State | MIA | 1 | 80 | -79 | 42 | Deon Butler (WR) - Penn State | SEA | 52 | 130 | -78 | 43 | Victor Butler (DE) - Oregon State | DAL | 1 | 76 | -75 | 44 | Alex Mack (OC) - California | CLE | 750 | 825 | -75 | 45 | Sherrod Martin (CB) - Troy | CAR | 241 | 315 | -74 | 46 | Glover Quin (S) - New Mexico | HOU | 1 | 72 | -71 | 47 | Vaughn Martin (DT) - Western Ontario | SD | 1 | 70 | -69 | 48 | Brian Robiskie (WR) - Ohio State | CLE | 470 | 540 | -70 | 49 | Mike Goodson (RB) - Texas A&M | CAR | 5 | 74 | -69 | 50 | Lardarius Webb (CB) - Nicholls State
| BAL | 76 | 143 | -67 | 51 | David Bruton (S) - Notre Dame | DEN | 2 | 68 | -66 | 52 | Alex Magee (DT) - Purdue | KC | 193 | 254 | -61 | 53 | Stanley Arnoux (MLB) - Wake Forest
| NO | 1 | 60 | -59 | 54 | Cody Brown (OLB) - Connecticut | ARI | 223 | 283 | -60 | 55 | Travis Beckum (TE) - Wisconsin (Inj) | NYG | 42 | 99 | -57 | 56 | Stephen McGee (QB) - Texas A&M | DAL | 39 | 96 | -57 | 57 | Antoine Caldwell (OC) - Alabama | HOU | 143 | 198 | -55 | 58 | *Knowshon Moreno (RB) - Georgia | DEN | 1050 | 1100 | -50 | 59 | Rich Ohrnberger (OG) - Penn State | NE | 1 | 50 | -49 | 60 | Slade Norris (DE) - Oregon State | OAK | 1 | 46 | -45 | 61 | *Austin Collie (WR) - BYU | IND | 1 | 45 | -44 | 62 | Greg Toler (CB) - St. Paul's College | ARI | 1 | 41 | -40 | 63 | Scott Olsen (OG) - Iowa | DEN | 1 | 40 | -39 | 64 | *Shonn Greene (RB) - Iowa | NYJ | 229 | 268 | -39 | 65 | Gartrell Johnson (RB) - Colorado State | SD | 1 | 39 | -38 | 66 | William Middleton (CB) - Furman | ATL | 1 | 37 | -36 | 67 | Colin Brown (OT) - Missouri | KC | 1 | 36 | -35 | 68 | Kevin Huber (P) - Cincinnati | CIN | 1 | 35 | -34 | 69 | Jarrett Dillard (WR) - Rice
| JAC | 1 | 34 | -33 | 70 | Quinn Johnson (FB) - LSU | GB | 1 | 34 | -33 | 71 | Davon Drew (TE) - East Carolina | BAL | 1 | 32 | -31 | 72 | Chase Coffman (TE) - Missouri | CIN | 74 | 105 | -31 | 73 | Brandon Hughes (CB) - Oregon State | SD | 2 | 32 | -30 | 74 | Kraig Urbik (OG) - Wisconsin | PIT | 158 | 188 | -30 | 75 | Roy Miller (DT) - Texas | TB | 148 | 178 | -30 | 76 | Sammie Lee Hill (DT) - Stillman | DET | 36 | 66 | -30 | 77 | Anthony Hill (TE) - North Carolina State (Inj) | HOU | 23 | 52 | -29 | 78 | Cody Glenn (LB) - Nebraska | WAS | 1 | 28 | -27 | 79 | Dorell Scott (DT) - Clemson | STL | 62 | 90 | -28 | 80 | Phil Loadholt (OT) - Oklahoma | MIN | 332 | 360 | -28 | 81 | John Nalbone (TE) - Monmouth
| MIA | 1 | 27 | -26 | 82 | Kenny McKinley (WR) - South Carolina | DEN | 9 | 36 | -27 | 83 | Thomas Morstead (P) - SMU | NO | 1 | 26 | -25 | 84 | Malcolm Jenkins (CB) - Ohio State | NO | 975 | 1000 | -25 | 85 | Frank Summers (RB) - UNLV | PIT | 1 | 24 | -23 | 86 | George Bussey (OG) - Louisville
| NE | 1 | 23 | -22 | 87 | *Sen'Derrick Marks (DT) - Auburn | TEN | 268 | 291 | -23 | 88 | Xavier Fulton (OT) - Illinois | TB | 7 | 29 | -22 | 89 | David Buehler (K) - Southern Cal | DAL | 1 | 23 | -22 | 90 | Tom Brandstater (QB) - Fresno State | DEN | 1 | 22 | -21 | 91 | Quinton Lawrence (WR) - McNeese State
| KC | 1 | 21 | -20 | 92 | Spencer Adkins (LB) - Miami | ATL | 1 | 21 | -20 | 93 | Mike Teel (QB) - Rutgers | SEA | 1 | 20 | -19 | 94 | *Hakeem Nicks (WR) - North Carolina | NYG | 630 | 650 | -20 | 95 | Max Unger (OC) - Oregon | SEA | 390 | 410 | -20 | 96 | Ron Brace (DT) - Boston College | NE | 480 | 500 | -20 | 97 | Zach Miller (TE) - Nebraska-Omaha | JAC | 1 | 19 | -18 | 98 | Jarius Wynn (DE) - Georgia | GB | 1 | 19 | -18 | 99 | Don Carey (CB) - Norfolk State | CLE | 3 | 21 | -18 | 100 | Robert Henson (OLB) - TCU | WAS | 1 | 17 | -16 |