| Worst Individual Picks of the 2006 Draft |
| Rank | Player | Team | Ranked Value | Selected Value | Difference |
1 | *Donte Whitner (S) - OHIO STATE | BUF | 750 | 1625 | -875 | 2 | *Vincent Young (QB) - TEXAS | TEN | 1625 | 2500 | -875 | 3 | *Ernie Sims (OLB) - FLORIDA STATE | DET | 1100 | 1450 | -350 | 4 | Davin Joseph (OG) - OKLAHOMA | TB | 450 | 775 | -325 | 5 | Ryan Cook (OC) - NEW MEXICO | MIN | 74 | 390 | -316 | 6 | Roman Harper (S) - ALABAMA | NO | 163 | 470 | -307 | 7 | John McCargo (DT) - NC STATE | BUF | 420 | 710 | -290 | 8 | *Bernard Pollard (S) - PURDUE | KC | 70 | 360 | -290 | 9 | Tamba Hali (DE) - PENN ST | KC | 610 | 850 | -240 | 10 | Tarvaris Jackson (QB) - ALABAMA STATE | MIN | 40 | 275 | -235 | 11 | Bobby Carpenter (OLB) - OHIO STATE | DAL | 670 | 900 | -230 | 12 | Manny Lawson (DE) - NORTH CAROLINA ST | SF | 590 | 800 | -210 | 13 | Paul McQuistan (OT) - WEBER STATE | OAK | 43 | 241 | -198 | 14 | Chris Gocong (OLB) - CAL POLY | PHI | 36 | 229 | -193 | 15 | Kellen Clemens (QB) - OREGON | NYJ | 218 | 410 | -192 | 16 | *Antonio Cromartie (CB) - FLORIDA STATE | SD | 690 | 875 | -185 | 17 | Daniel Bullocks (S) - NEBRASKA | DET | 350 | 500 | -150 | 18 | *Mario Williams (DE) - NORTH CAROLINA ST | HOU | 2650 | 2800 | -150 | 19 | Clint Ingram (OLB) - OKLAHOMA | JAC | 34 | 183 | -149 | 20 | Daryn Colledge (OT) - BOISE STATE | GB | 283 | 430 | -147 | 21 | Anthony Schlegel (ILB) - OHIO STATE | NYJ | 62 | 203 | -141 | 22 | *Danieal Manning (CB) - ABILENE CHRISTIAN | CHI | 341 | 480 | -139 | 23 | Jeremy Trueblood (OT) - BOSTON COLLEGE | TB | 178 | 315 | -137 | 24 | Joel Klopfenstein (TE) - COLORADO | STL | 307 | 440 | -133 | 25 | Jerious Norwood (RB) - MISSISSIPPI STATE | ATL | 56 | 188 | -132 | 26 | Cedric Griffen (CB) - TEXAS | MIN | 291 | 420 | -129 | 27 | Joseph Addai (RB) - LSU | IND | 510 | 630 | -120 | 28 | Brandon Williams (WR) - WISCONSIN | SF | 45 | 163 | -118 | 29 | Jason Hatcher (DE) - GRAMBLING STATE | DAL | 12 | 126 | -114 | 30 | Kelly Jennings (CB) - MIAMI (FL) | SEA | 500 | 610 | -110 | 31 | Freddie Keiaho (ILB) - SAN DIEGO STATE | IND | 12 | 118 | -106 | 32 | *Devin Hester (CB) - MIAMI | CHI | 229 | 332 | -103 | 33 | Rashad Butler (OT) - MIAMI (FLA.) | CAR | 36 | 138 | -102 | 34 | Chris Chester (OC) - OKLAHOMA | BAL | 241 | 341 | -100 | 35 | Kamerion Wimbley (DE) - FLORIDA STATE | CLE | 950 | 1050 | -100 | 36 | Deuce Lutui (OG) - USC | ARI | 400 | 490 | -90 | 37 | Anthony Smith (S) - SYRACUSE | PIT | 78 | 168 | -90 | 38 | David Pittman (CB) - NORTHWESTERN ST | BAL | 60 | 148 | -88 | 39 | Willie Reid (WR) - FLORIDA STATE | PIT | 33 | 114 | -81 | 40 | Owen Daniels (TE) - WISCONSIN | HOU | 24 | 105 | -81 | 41 | Eric Smith (S) - MICHIGAN STATE | NYJ | 29 | 108 | -79 | 42 | Jon Alston (OLB) - STANFORD | STL | 122 | 198 | -76 | 43 | Jason Allen (CB) - TENNESSEE | MIA | 875 | 950 | -75 | 44 | Isaac Sowells (OT) - INDIANA | CLE | 1 | 72 | -71 | 45 | Roger McIntosh (OLB) - MIAMI (FLA.) | WAS | 480 | 550 | -70 | 46 | D'Qwell Jackson (ILB) - MARYLAND | CLE | 490 | 560 | -70 | 47 | Frostee Rucker (DE) - USC | CIN | 68 | 130 | -62 | 48 | *Cory Rodgers (WR) - TCU | GB | 28 | 88 | -60 | 49 | Stephen Gostkowski (PK) - MEMPHIS | NE | 1 | 60 | -59 | 50 | Travis Wilson (WR) - OKLAHOMA | CLE | 134 | 193 | -59 | 51 | Brandon Marshall (WR) - CENTRAL FLORIDA | DEN | 1 | 58 | -57 | 52 | Tim Jennings (CB) - GEORGIA | IND | 235 | 291 | -56 | 53 | *Anthony Fasano (TE) - NOTRE DAME | DAL | 315 | 370 | -55 | 54 | Michael Robinson (WR) - PENN ST | SF | 46 | 99 | -53 | 55 | James Anderson (OLB) - VIRGINIA TECH | CAR | 90 | 143 | -53 | 56 | Thomas Howard (OLB) - UTEP | OAK | 470 | 520 | -50 | 57 | Tye Hill (CB) - CLEMSON | STL | 925 | 975 | -50 | 58 | Garret Mills (FB) - TULSA | NE | 37 | 84 | -47 | 59 | *Maurice Drew (RB) - UCLA | JAC | 261 | 307 | -46 | 60 | Brad Smith (WR) - MISSOURI | NYJ | 47 | 90 | -43 | 61 | Domenik Hixon (WR) - AKRON | DEN | 1 | 42 | -41 | 62 | Willie Colon (OT) - HOFSTRA | PIT | 1 | 41 | -40 | 63 | Charlie Whitehurst (QB) - CLEMSON | SD | 138 | 178 | -40 | 64 | Quinn Ojinnaka (OT) - SYRACUSE | ATL | 1 | 36 | -35 | 65 | David Thomas (TE) - TEXAS | NE | 118 | 153 | -35 | 66 | Leon Williams (ILB) - MIAMI (FLA.) | CLE | 44 | 76 | -32 | 67 | Ingle Martin (PT) - FURMAN | GB | 1 | 32 | -31 | 68 | Jason Pociask (TE) - WISCONSIN | NYJ | 1 | 31 | -30 | 69 | Damato Peko (DT) - MICHIGAN STATE | CIN | 19 | 50 | -31 | 70 | Marcus Maxey (CB) - MIAMI | KC | 1 | 30 | -29 | 71 | Brent Hawkins (DE) - ILLINOIS STATE | JAC | 1 | 27 | -26 | 72 | Calvin Lowry (S) - PENN ST | TEN | 66 | 93 | -27 | 73 | Michael Toudouze (OT) - TEXAS CHRISTIAN | IND | 1 | 27 | -26 | 74 | Chris Kuper (OG) - NORTH DAKOTA | DEN | 1 | 27 | -26 | 75 | David Kirtman (FB) - USC | SEA | 1 | 26 | -25 | 76 | Jahri Evans (OG) - BLOOMSBURG | NO | 54 | 80 | -26 | 77 | Tony Moll (OT) - NEVADA | GB | 1 | 25 | -24 | 78 | *Laurence Maroney (RB) - MINNESOTA | NE | 800 | 825 | -25 | 79 | Chad Greenway (OLB) - IOWA | MIN | 900 | 925 | -25 | 80 | Quinn Sypniewski (TE) - COLORADO | BAL | 1 | 25 | -24 | 81 | Jamar Williams (OLB) - ARIZONA STATE | CHI | 33 | 56 | -23 | 82 | Reed Doughty (S) - NORTHERN COLORADO | WAS | 1 | 22 | -21 | 83 | Delanie Walker (WR) - CENTRAL MISSOURI STATE | SF | 1 | 21 | -20 | 84 | Jonathon Orr (WR) - WISCONSIN | TEN | 2 | 23 | -21 | 85 | Wali Lundy (RB) - VIRGINIA | HOU | 3 | 23 | -20 | 86 | Alton McCann (CB) - WEST VIRGINIA | DET | 2 | 20 | -18 | 87 | Adam Jennings (WR) - FRESNO STATE | ATL | 1 | 18 | -17 | 88 | Tyrone Culver (S) - FRESNO STATE | GB | 1 | 17 | -16 | 89 | Tre' Stallings (OG) - MISSISSIPPI | KC | 1 | 17 | -16 | 90 | Jeromey Clary (OT) - KANSAS STATE | SD | 1 | 17 | -16 | 91 | Kurt Smith (PK) - VIRGINIA | SD | 1 | 16 | -15 | 92 | Joe Toledo (OT) - WASHINGTON | MIA | 52 | 68 | -16 | 93 | Drew Coleman (CB) - TEXAS CHRISTIAN | NYJ | 1 | 16 | -15 | 94 | Marcus Hudson (S) - NORTH CAROLINA ST | SF | 1 | 16 | -15 | 95 | Mathias Kiwanuka (DE) - BOSTON COLLEGE | NYG | 575 | 590 | -15 | 96 | Mike Hass (WR) - OREGON STATE | NO | 9 | 23 | -14 | 97 | Melvin Oliver (DE) - LSU | SF | 1 | 14 | -13 | 98 | Charles Davis (TE) - PURDUE | PIT | 11 | 25 | -14 | 99 | Jeff Webb (WR) - SAN DIEGO STATE | KC | 2 | 15 | -13 | 100 | Brad Butler (OT) - VIRGINIA | BUF | 21 | 34 | -13 |
