Ask The Commish.com - Computer Generated Mock Draft

How this works: The Commish started by ranking the 550+ players that we feel could be drafted. We then reviewed the needs of each NFL team and ranked those needs as follows:

5: Immediate and critical need.
4. Immediate need.
3. Not an immediate need, but a position that should be addressed.
2. The team could consider drafting for depth.
1. The team is set and should only draft if the value is too good to pass up.

We then generated a formula that would weigh need against "best player available" to generate this mock draft. The results are listed below.

Since the scouts' views on players change frequently, our individual rankings will likewise change on a regular basis, which means that the Computer Generated Mock Draft will change as well.

So, please check back on a daily basis for the latest and greatest!

Round 1
Draft Position	Team	Player	Position	Size	School
1	SF	Braylon Edwards	WR	6-3, 205	Michigan
2	MIA	*Mike Williams	WR	6-4, 230	Southern California
3	CLE	Derrick Johnson	OLB	6-3, 240	Texas
4	CHI	Antrel Rolle	CB	6-1, 200	Miami
5	TB	Alex Barron	OT	6-6, 310	Florida State
6	TEN	*Troy Williamson	WR	6-2, 200	South Carolina
7	MIN	*Alex Smith	QB	6-4, 215	Utah
8	ARI	*Aaron Rodgers	QB	6-2, 220	California
9	WAS	*Shawne Merriman	DE	6-4, 260	Maryland
10	DET	*Adam Jones	CB	5-11, 185	West Virginia
11	DAL	Carlos Rogers	CB	6-1, 195	Auburn
12	SD	Marcus Spears	DE	6-4, 295	LSU
13	NO	Travis Johnson	DT	6-5, 295	Florida State
14	CAR	*Heath Miller	TE	6-5, 255	Virginia
15	KC	Mark Clayton	WR	5-11, 190	Oklahoma
16	HOU	Jammal Brown	OT	6-6, 315	Oklahoma
17	CIN	Shaun Cody	DT	6-4, 293	USC
18	MIN	Ronnie Brown	RB	6-0, 230	Auburn
19	STL	David Pollack	DE	6-3, 275	Georgia
20	DAL	*Thomas Davis	SS	6-1, 230	Georgia
21	JAC	*Fabian Washington	CB	5-10, 180	Nebraska
22	BAL	Demarcus Ware	DE	6-4, 239	Troy
23	OAK	Jason Campbell	QB	6-5, 230	Auburn
24	GB	Cedric Benson	RB	5-10, 220	Texas
25	WAS	Marlin Jackson	CB	6-1, 200	Michigan
26	SEA	Roddy White	WR	6-1, 200	Alabama-Birmingham
27	ATL	Khalif Barnes	OT	6-5, 290	Washington
28	SD	Matt Jones	WR	6-6, 237	Arkansas
29	IND	Carnell Williams	RB	5-11, 205	Auburn
30	PIT	*Justin Miller	CB	5-11, 200	Clemson
31	PHI	Erasmus James	DE	6-4, 260	Wisconsin
32	NE	Marcus Johnson	OT	6-6, 315	Mississippi

* Denotes Underclassmen

Round 2
Draft Position	Team	Player	Position	Size	School
33	SF	Dan Cody	DE	6-5, 270	Oklahoma
34	CLE	Matt Roth	DE	6-4, 270	Iowa
35	PHI	*Channing Crowder	ILB	6-2, 250	Florida
36	TB	Elton Brown	OG	6-5, 335	Virginia
37	DET	*Brodney Pool	FS	6-3, 200	Oklahoma
38	OAK	*Darryl Blackstock	OLB	6-3, 235	Virginia
39	CHI	Kevin Burnett	OLB	6-3, 235	Tennessee
40	NO	David Baas	C	6-5, 310	Michigan
41	TEN	Luis Castillo	DT	6-3, 305	Northwestern
42	DAL	Barrett Ruud	ILB	6-2, 240	Nebraska
43	NYG	Corey Webster	CB	6-0, 200	LSU
44	ARI	Mike Patterson	DT	6-0, 290	USC
45	SEA	*Josh Bullocks	FS	6-0, 205	Nebraska
46	MIA	Adam Terry	OT	6-8, 325	Syracuse
47	NYJ	*Chris Spencer	C	6-3, 310	Mississippi
48	CIN	Alex Smith	TE	6-5, 255	Stanford
49	MIN	*Odell Thurman	ILB	6-1, 230	Georgia
50	STL	Reggie Brown	WR	6-1, 195	Georgia
51	GB	*Brandon Browner	FS	6-4, 200	Oregon State
52	JAC	*Justin Tuck	DE	6-4, 255	Notre Dame
53	BAL	Jonathan Babineaux	DT	6-2, 286	Iowa
54	CAR	*Chris Henry	WR	6-4, 200	West Virginia
55	BUF	Logan Mankins	OT	6-4, 320	Fresno State
56	DEN	Jerome Mathis	WR	5-10, 175	Hampton
57	NYJ	Charlie Frye	QB	6-4, 225	Akron
58	GB	*Ernest Shazor	SS	6-3, 225	Michigan
59	ATL	*Roscoe Parrish	WR	5-9, 175	Miami
60	IND	Bryant McFadden	CB	6-0, 190	Florida State
61	SD	Ray Willis	OT	6-6, 320	Florida State
62	PIT	J.J. Arrington	RB	5-9, 212	California
63	PHI	*Ciatrick Fason	RB	6-1, 210	Florida
64	BAL	Eric Green	CB	5-11, 198	Virginia Tech

* Denotes Underclassmen

Round 3
Draft Position	Team	Player	Position	Size	School
65	SF	Stanford Routt	CB	6-1, 195	Houston
66	STL	*C.J. Mosley	DT	6-3, 305	Missouri
67	CLE	Antonio Perkins	CB	5-11, 190	Oklahoma
68	TEN	Chris Canty	DE	6-6, 280	Virginia
69	OAK	Atiyyah Ellison	DT	6-4, 305	Missouri
70	MIA	Anttaj Hawthorne	DT	6-3, 321	Wisconsin
71	TB	Terrance Murphy	WR	6-1, 195	Texas A&M
72	DET	Chris Colmer	OT	6-6, 320	North Carolina State
73	HOU	*Eric Shelton	RB	6-2, 245	Louisville
74	NYG	Wesley Britt	OT	6-7, 315	Alabama
75	ARI	Evan Mathis	OG	6-5, 310	Alabama
76	DEN	Donte Nicholson	SS	6-0, 210	Oklahoma
77	PHI	Ronald Fields	DT	6-2, 325	Mississippi State
78	OAK	Stanley Wilson	CB	6-0, 185	Stanford
79	CAR	Ronald Bartell Jr.	CB	6-1, 210	Howard
80	MIN	Mike Nugent	K	5-10, 170	Ohio State
81	STL	Domonique Foxworth	CB	5-11, 180	Maryland
82	NO	*Matt McCoy	OLB	6-1, 230	San Diego State
83	CIN	Darrent Williams	CB	5-9, 175	Oklahoma State
84	NE	Vincent Jackson	WR	6-5, 235	Northern Colorado
85	SEA	Gerald Sensabaugh	SS	6-2, 215	North Carolina
86	BUF	Vince Fuller	FS	6-1, 190	Virginia Tech
87	JAC	Michael Boley	OLB	6-3, 220	Southern Mississippi
88	NYJ	Courtney Roby	WR	6-0, 185	Indiana
89	CAR	Sean Considine	FS	6-0, 205	Iowa
90	ATL	Oshiomogho Atogwe	FS	5-11, 205	Stanford
91	TB	Kirk Morrison	ILB	6-3, 240	San Diego State
92	IND	Alfred Fincher	ILB	6-1, 240	Connecticut
93	PIT	Fred Gibson	WR	6-4, 200	Georgia
94	SF	Jordan Beck	OLB	6-2, 230	Cal-Poly State
95	ARI	Kevin Everett	TE	6-4, 250	Miami
96	TEN	Michael Munoz	OT	6-5, 315	Tennessee
97	DEN	*Jovan Haye	DE	6-3, 280	Vanderbilt
98	SEA	David Greene	QB	6-1, 225	Georgia
99	KC	Andrew Walter	QB	6-5, 235	Arizona State
100	NE	*Vernand Morency	RB	5-10, 215	Oklahoma State
101	DEN	Michael Roos	OT	6-6, 295	Eastern Washington

* Denotes Underclassmen

Round 4
Draft Position	Team	Player	Position	Size	School
102	PHI	Craphonso Thorpe	WR	6-0, 190	Florida State
103	CLE	*Lofa Tatupu	ILB	5-11, 235	USC
104	MIA	LeRoy Hill	OLB	6-1, 225	Clemson
105	SEA	Ben Wilkerson	C	6-3, 300	LSU
106	CHI	Adam Snyder	OG	6-4, 325	Oregon
107	TB	Nick Collins	CB	5-11, 205	Bethune-Cookman
108	TEN	Kyle Orton	QB	6-4, 225	Purdue
109	DAL	Mark Bradley	WR	6-2, 200	Oklahoma
110	NYG	Robert McCune	ILB	6-2, 240	Louisville
111	ARI	Jerome Carter	SS	6-2, 220	Florida State
112	MIN	Roydell Williams	WR	6-1, 190	Tulane
113	TEN	Chris Kemoeatu	OG	6-4, 340	Utah
114	HOU	Dan Buenning	OG	6-4, 315	Wisconsin
115	GB	Anthony Bryant	DT	6-2, 335	Alabama
116	KC	Trent Cole	DE	6-4, 250	Cincinnati
117	STL	James Butler	FS	6-2, 210	Georgia Tech
118	NO	Taylor Stubblefield	WR	6-0, 175	Purdue
119	CIN	Jonathan Welsh	DE	6-3, 244	Wisconsin
120	WAS	Darrell Shropshire	DT	6-2, 301	South Carolina
121	CAR	*Marion Barber III	RB	5-11, 219	Minnesota
122	BUF	Joel Dreessen	TE	6-4, 260	Colorado State
123	NYJ	Nick Kaczur	OG	6-4, 320	Toledo
124	BAL	Marviel Underwood	FS	6-1, 200	San Diego State
125	GB	Jason Brown	C	6-3, 315	North Carolina
126	PHI	Jeremy Parquet	OT	6-6, 325	Southern Mississippi
127	JAC	*Ryan Moats	RB	5-7, 180	Louisiana Tech
128	ATL	Travis Daniels	CB	6-0, 190	LSU
129	IND	Sione Pouha	DT	6-3, 325	Utah
130	SD	Scott Young	OG	6-4, 310	BYU
131	PIT	Jonathan Goddard	DE	6-0, 240	Marshall
132	DAL	Adrian McPherson	QB	6-3, 220	Arena Football
133	NE	Junior Rosegreen	SS	6-0, 195	Auburn
134	STL	Andre Maddox	SS	6-1, 205	North Carolina State
135	IND	Bill Swancutt	DE	6-4, 260	Oregon State
136	TEN	Marcus Lawrence	ILB	6-2, 240	South Carolina

* Denotes Underclassmen

Round 5
Draft Position	Team	Player	Position	Size	School
137	SF	Dustin Colquitt	P	6-1, 190	Tennessee
138	KC	Todd Herremans	OT	6-6, 313	Saginaw Valley State
139	CLE	Airese Currie	WR	5-11, 185	Clemson
140	CHI	Lance Mitchell	ILB	6-3, 245	Oklahoma
141	TB	*Richie Incognito	C	6-3, 305	Nebraska
142	TEN	Vince Carter	C	6-4, 295	Oklahoma
143	GB	Adam Seward	ILB	6-2, 250	UNLV
144	STL	Darren Sproles	RB	5-6, 180	Kansas State
145	DET	Vincent Burns	DE	6-2, 270	Kentucky
146	PHI	*T.A. McLendon	RB	5-11, 225	North Carolina State
147	KC	Lynn McGruder	DT	6-3, 300	Oklahoma
148	IND	Pete McMahon	OT	6-7, 330	Iowa
149	CAR	Anthony Davis	RB	5-7, 195	Wisconsin
150	TEN	Dustin Fox	CB	5-11, 190	Ohio State
151	HOU	J.R. Russell	WR	6-3, 205	Louisville
152	NO	David Stewart	OT	6-5, 315	Mississippi State
153	CIN	James Grigsby	ILB	6-0, 240	Illinois State
154	WAS	Alvin Pearman	RB	5-10, 200	Virginia
155	TB	Cedric Houston	RB	6-0, 215	Tennessee
156	BUF	Justin Geisinger	OG	6-4, 325	Vanderbilt
157	JAC	Junius Coston	C	6-3, 310	North Carolina A&T
158	BAL	Dan Orlovsky	QB	6-5, 230	Connecticut
159	SEA	Lorenzo Alexander	DT	6-2, 300	California
160	ATL	Albert Means	DT	6-4, 340	Memphis
161	NYJ	Lionel Gates	RB	6-0, 220	Louisville
162	MIA	James Sanders	FS	5-11, 205	Fresno State
163	ATL	Brandon Jacobs	RB	6-4, 260	Southern Illinois
164	SD	Kerry Rhodes	FS	6-2, 210	Louisville
165	IND	Claude Terrell	OG	6-3, 330	New Mexico
166	PIT	Chris Myers	OG	6-4, 290	Miami
167	GB	Leron McCoy	WR	6-1, 200	Indiana (Pa.)
168	ARI	Anthony Alabi	OT	6-6, 325	Texas Christian
169	CAR	*Damien Nash	RB	5-11, 215	Missouri
170	NE	Scott Starks	CB	5-8, 175	Wisconsin
171	CAR	Ben Emanuel	SS	6-3, 225	UCLA
172	PHI	*Rian Wallace	OLB	6-3, 240	Temple
173	IND	Adam Bergen	TE	6-5, 255	Lehigh
174	SF	Joe Berger	OG	6-5, 290	Michigan Tech

* Denotes Underclassmen

Round 6
Draft Position	Team	Player	Position	Size	School
175	OAK	Ryan Riddle	DE	6-2, 255	California
176	CLE	Stefon LeFors	QB	6-0, 205	Louisville
177	SD	Derek Anderson	QB	6-5, 239	Oregon State
178	TB	Brady Poppinga	DE	6-3, 260	BYU
179	TEN	Kay-Jay Harris	RB	6-0, 235	West Virginia
180	GB	Sam Mayes	OG	6-3, 350	Oklahoma State
181	CHI	Craig Bragg	WR	6-1, 200	UCLA
182	NYJ	Karl Paymah	CB	6-0, 205	Washington State
183	WAS	Rob Petitti	OT	6-6, 330	Pittsburgh
184	DET	C.J. Brooks	OG	6-5, 320	Maryland
185	JAC	*Larry Brackins	WR	6-4, 205	Pearl River CC
186	NYG	Santonio Thomas	DT	6-2, 300	Miami
187	KC	Kelvin Hayden	CB	5-11, 200	Illinois
188	HOU	Antwaun Rogers	CB	6-2, 180	Purdue
189	CAR	Wes Sims	OG	6-5, 310	Oklahoma
190	CIN	Kyle Wallace	OT	6-5, 291	Georgia Tech
191	MIN	Adell Duckett	DE	6-4, 265	Texas Tech
192	STL	Marques Harris	OLB	6-1, 230	Southern Utah
193	NO	Zac Woodfin	ILB	6-2, 235	Alabama-Birmingham
194	JAC	James Kinney	ILB	6-0, 240	Missouri
195	GB	Walter Reyes	RB	5-10, 210	Syracuse
196	SEA	George Gause	DE	6-5, 270	South Carolina
197	BUF	Mike Montgomery	DT	6-6, 280	Texas A&M
198	NYJ	Jason Jefferson	DT	6-2, 305	Wisconsin
199	KC	Jonathan Clinkscale	OG	6-4, 305	Wisconsin
200	DEN	*Frank Gore	RB	5-9, 220	Miami
201	ATL	Brandon Jones	WR	6-2, 210	Oklahoma
202	IND	Justin Beriault	SS	6-3, 205	Ball State
203	CLE	Garrett Cross	TE	6-4, 230	California
204	PIT	Orrin Thompson	DT	6-6, 308	Duke
205	SF	Mike Goolsby	ILB	6-3, 245	Notre Dame
206	DET	*Steve Savoy	WR	5-11, 190	Utah
207	CAR	Calvin Armstrong	OT	6-7, 310	Washington State
208	NYG	Scott Mruczkowski	C	6-4, 319	Bowling Green
209	NYG	Doug Buckles	OG	6-5, 300	Mississippi
210	STL	Zach Tuiasosopo	FB	6-2, 250	Washington
211	PHI	Alex Holmes	TE	6-3, 270	USC
212	NYJ	Jon Dunn	OT	6-6, 340	Virginia Tech
213	BAL	Josh Davis	WR	6-1, 190	Marshall
214	NYJ	Chauncey Davis	DE	6-2, 279	Florida State

* Denotes Underclassmen

Round 7
Draft Position	Team	Player	Position	Size	School
215	SF	Marquis Weeks	FS	5-10, 216	Virginia
216	MIA	Derrick Johnson	CB	5-11, 195	Washington
217	CLE	Jimmy Verdon	DT	6-4, 280	Arizona State
218	TEN	Chauncey Stovall	WR	6-1, 215	Florida State
219	MIN	Ellis Hobbs	CB	5-9, 190	Iowa State
220	CHI	Dave Kashetta	TE	6-4, 251	Boston College
221	TB	Billy Bajema	TE	6-5, 255	Oklahoma State
222	WAS	Diamond Ferri	SS	5-10, 220	Syracuse
223	SF	Eric Pears	OT	6-8, 315	Colorado State
224	DAL	Simon Fraser	DE	6-6, 255	Ohio State
225	TB	Ryan Claridge	OLB	6-2, 255	UNLV
226	ARI	Jason Anderson	WR	6-2, 195	Wake Forest
227	HOU	Tyjuan Hagler	OLB	6-0, 235	Cincinnati
228	PIT	Rob Hunt	C	6-4, 300	North Dakota
229	KC	*Dante Ridgeway	WR	5-11, 210	Ball State
230	NE	*A.J. Lindsay	DT	6-3, 310	Temple
231	TB	Aric Williams	CB	5-11, 185	Oregon State
232	NO	Bryan Randall	QB	6-0, 222	Virginia Tech
233	CIN	Geoff Hangartner	C	6-5, 305	Texas A&M
234	BAL	Jammal Brimmer	SS	6-1, 215	UNLV
235	SEA	Bo Scaife	TE	6-3, 250	Texas
236	BUF	Andre Frazier	DE	6-5, 235	Cincinnati
237	JAC	Eric Knott	TE	6-3, 249	Michigan State
238	KC	Derek Wake	OLB	6-2, 240	Penn State
239	DEN	Daven Holly	CB	5-10, 192	Cincinnati
240	NYJ	Cedrick Williams	CB	5-10, 170	Kansas State
241	ATL	Drew Hodgdon	C	6-3, 305	Arizona State
242	SD	Chris McKenzie	CB	5-8, 185	Arizona State
243	IND	Daniel Loper	OT	6-6, 325	Texas Tech
244	PIT	Doug Nienhuis	OT	6-5, 310	Oregon State
245	GB	Kenneth Pettway	OLB	6-3, 235	Grambling State
246	GB	Dave Rayner	K	6-2, 205	Michigan State
247	PHI	Dan Connolly	OG	6-4, 310	SE Missouri State
248	SF	Chris Harris	SS	6-2, 214	Louisiana-Monroe
249	SF	Tim Bulman	DT	6-3, 294	Boston College
250	STL	Timmy Chang	QB	6-2, 196	Hawaii
251	STL	Jonathan Pollard	ILB	6-1, 247	Oregon State
252	PHI	Alphonso Hodge	CB	5-11, 203	Miami (OH)
253	TB	Derreck Robinson	DT	6-4, 290	Iowa
254	SEA	Jonathan Colon	OT	6-7, 317	Florida
255	NE	Dylan Gandy	OG	6-3, 295	Texas Tech

* Denotes Underclassmen

Schedule

Week 1
TEN vs PIT	8:30	NBC
NYJ vs HOU	1:00	CBS
MIA vs ATL	1:00
DEN vs CIN	1:00
MIN vs CLE	1:00
JAC vs IND	1:00
DET vs NO	1:00
DAL vs TB	1:00
PHI vs CAR	1:00
KC vs BAL	1:00
WAS vs NYG	4:15
SF vs ARI	4:15
STL vs SEA	4:15
CHI vs GB	8:20
BUF vs NE	7:00
SD vs OAK	10:15
Entire NFL Schedule

Subscribe to Free Newsletter

Top 2005 NFL Draft Prospects By Position

2005 NFL Mock Draft

The Top Ten 2005 Fantasy Prospects

Ask The Commish.com's Projected NFL Draft Pick Value Chart

2005 NFL Mock Draft - Round 2

NFL Merchandise
New York Jets Team Merchandise